Tactics Explained
Premier League · 2026/27 · Michael Carrick · updated 9 Nov

Manchester United

Big matches, broken down move by move. Big matches get a full animated analysis; every match gets its score, xG and a graded prediction.

Tap a highlighted match to open its analysis. The dashed card at the end is the next match's preview.

Looking forward

Next match: Liverpool vs Manchester United

Liverpool
v
Manchester United
Premier League · Matchday 11Sun 22 Nov 202616:30 GMT · 01:30 KST (Mon)Anfield, Liverpool

United go to Anfield 18th, after coming from two down in each of their last two games; Liverpool are fourth after a 3–1 win at Crystal Palace. United won both meetings last season.

Win probability

Manchester United win 27% · draw 21% · Liverpool win 52%. Expected goals 1.47–2.09.

What to watch

  • The space behind United's full-backs: Against Villa both United full-backs pushed on, and Villa's penalty came when Alysson ran at Dalot on United's left (avfc.co.uk); both Roma goals came from the same side. Liverpool's wide forwards, Gakpo and Barcola at Palace, will look for that space when United lose the ball.
  • The first quarter of an hour: United were 2–0 down after 3 minutes 40 seconds against Villa (Opta Analyst) and two down at half-time against Roma. Coming back worked twice at Old Trafford; doing it at Anfield is harder.
  • Dead balls: Villa's fourth came from a free kick Yoro headed onto his own woodwork, and United's equaliser from a Fernandes corner. Liverpool's opener at Palace was Mac Allister heading in Szoboszlai's free kick (FotMob).
  • The first goal: In the Tactics Lab engine, United's recent shape away to Liverpool's (shapes and instructions only) scores first in 38 runs in 100, and averages 1.68 points when it does and 0.38 when it doesn't. It sees no players, no form and no injuries.

Liverpool: how they play

  • Coach and shape: Andoni Iraola. A 4-2-3-1 at Selhurst Park: Alisson; Araujo, Jacquet, van Dijk, Kerkez; Szoboszlai and Mac Allister; Gakpo, Wirtz and Barcola behind Isak (FotMob).
  • With the ball: 53.6% possession on average after nine league games, seventh in the league, and 385 accurate passes a game, also seventh (FotMob). At Palace they had only 46% of it.
  • Chances: about 15.8 xG in ten league games (FotMob match figures added up). Isak has seven league goals (premierleague.com); Wirtz scored his first of the season at Palace (FotMob).
  • Without the ball: before Palace they had conceded 1.0 goals a game, fourth-fewest, and kept four clean sheets, third-most (FotMob). Alisson made four saves in the first half at Selhurst Park (FotMob).
  • Where it breaks: Palace made 2.60 xG to Liverpool's 2.65, hit the crossbar and had a goal ruled out for offside (FotMob). The week before, Liverpool lost 1–0 at home to Arsenal and 3–2 at Fenerbahçe (Sky Sports).
Looking back

Season so far

Manchester United have created 26.98 xG and scored 24 in 15 games. Opponents: 26.03 xG, 30 goals. In the league, 8 points from 10 games against 13.0 expected.

Premier League, top of the table after Matchday 10

#TeamPGDPts
1Arsenal10+1027
2Brighton & Hove Albion10+1922
3Manchester City10+821
4Liverpool10+418
5Chelsea10+316
6Everton10+216
7Manchester United10-58

Chances, match by match

Bars: expected goals (xG) created. Rings: actual goals. ■ Manchester United ■ Opponent

Goals vs expected, running total

Solid: actual goals. Dashed: xG. Manchester United in the team colour, opponents in the contrast colour.

League points vs expected points

Expected points: the points the chances deserved, from each Premier League match's xG.

Every result, judged by the chances

DateCompOpponentScorexGW / D / L from the chancesVerdictPre-match model
22 AugPLHull City0–21.83–1.0157% / 23% / 21%Unlucky–
30 AugPLIpswich Town5–24.77–2.0680% / 9% / 10%Deserved–
6 SepPLEverton2–20.69–1.0124% / 33% / 42%Fair–
10 SepUCLSabah FK4–03.54–0.8486% / 9% / 5%Deserved–
13 SepPLManchester City0–11.00–1.1032% / 30% / 38%Deserved loss–
16 SepEFLBrighton & Hove Albion2–31.20–2.1421% / 20% / 59%Deserved loss–
20 SepPLFulham1–11.60–1.6238% / 23% / 39%Fair–
10 OctPLTottenham Hotspur1–10.80–1.6218% / 25% / 57%Fair69% / 18% / 14% Missed
13 OctUCLAtlético de Madrid0–20.98–1.4725% / 26% / 48%Deserved loss26% / 22% / 53% Called it
18 OctPLLeeds United1–10.92–1.4125% / 27% / 48%Fair41% / 24% / 36% Missed
21 OctUCLComo 19071–40.99–2.1117% / 20% / 63%Deserved loss23% / 22% / 55% Called it
25 OctPLAFC Bournemouth0–31.17–2.1520% / 20% / 60%Deserved loss48% / 22% / 30% Missed
31 OctPLChelsea0–21.24–3.0113% / 14% / 73%Deserved loss33% / 22% / 45% Called it
3 NovUCLAS Roma3–22.70–1.6061% / 18% / 21%Deserved27% / 21% / 52% Missed
8 NovPLAston Villa4–43.55–2.8852% / 16% / 32%Points dropped52% / 22% / 26% Missed

“W / D / L from the chances” replays each match with the same xG using a Poisson model. xG: FotMob (Opta) for every match, using FotMob's final figure (for Como it is 0.99–2.11; Opta Analyst's full-time number was 1.05–2.04; for Chelsea it is 1.24–3.01 including Palmer's penalty, Opta Analyst's half-time splits add up to 1.17–2.61; for Roma it is 2.70–1.60, ESPN has 2.72–1.53; for Aston Villa it is 3.55–2.88, the same as Sky Sports); table after Matchday 10: Sky Sports table after Saturday's games plus Sunday's five results (Brighton 2–0 Brentford, Crystal Palace 1–3 Liverpool, Sunderland 1–0 Chelsea, Ipswich 1–2 Bournemouth, Man United 4–4 Aston Villa; premierleague.com, Brentford FC, FotMob), United 18th. Priors: 2025/26 xG/xGA from Opta via Squawka (67 / 48 in 38 games); goals from the final table (69–50).

Column · Our take · 9 Nov 2026

United are making chances again, but they keep giving goals away and are 18th going into the break.

What's happening. Two comebacks in five days: a win over Roma from two down, then a draw with Aston Villa after trailing by two goals twice. It still leaves United 18th with one league win all season, the club's lowest position after ten games since 1986/87 (Opta Analyst). Next, after the international break, is Liverpool at Anfield.

How it works. Since half-time against Roma, United have pressed high and pushed both full-backs on. That makes chances: Villa spent most of Sunday in their own half. The cost is the space behind and how few defenders are left when the ball is lost or a dead ball is given away. Villa scored from a first-minute move, a parry, a penalty given away on the left and a free kick.

What the shots say. United out-created Villa (FotMob), the second game running after six in which the opponent made more. Over the league season they have scored fewer goals than their chances deserve and conceded more. One reading: the attack is working, and the goals against are mistakes that can be coached out. The other: a side that has conceded more than anyone in Europe's top five leagues (Opta Analyst) has a defending problem, not a luck problem.

Take it to your own tactic
  • In FM26: two full-backs on Wing-Back with Attacking Width: Wider fills the box, but keep a Defensive Midfielder or a Holding Full-Back behind them so a turnover is not a foot race.
  • On the pitch: when both full-backs go, someone has to stay. Agree before the game who covers the space behind them and how many players stay behind the ball.
RiskIf United keep out-creating opponents at Anfield and stop conceding early and from dead balls, the table will start to follow the chances. If Liverpool find the space behind the full-backs as Villa did, the chances United make will not be enough.
Our data lens

Manchester United, read from every shot

Loading the data lens…

Match by match

Analyses

PLManchester United · 8 NovManchester United 4–4 Aston Villa

Villa led 2–0 after four minutes and 4–2 after 53. United, with 26 shots to Villa's 12, drew level with two goals in stoppage time and are still 18th.

8 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
UCLManchester United · 3 NovManchester United 3–2 AS Roma

Two down at half-time against Roma's man-for-man press, United pressed back: a retaken Fernandes penalty and two Cunha goals in three minutes ended nine games without a win.

5 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 31 OctChelsea 2–0 Manchester United

United were the better side for 45 minutes. Then Lavia took the ball off Mbeumo, Rogers ran through, Martínez was sent off and Palmer scored the penalty: nine games without a win.

2 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 25 OctManchester United 0–3 AFC Bournemouth

Fernandes on the bench, 63% of the ball, three errors punished: Bournemouth won 3–0 and United are eight games without a win.

3 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
UCLManchester United · 21 OctComo 1907 4–1 Manchester United

United stood off, Nico Paz lived in the space in front of their back four, and Como won 4–1: seven games without a win.

5 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 18 OctLeeds United 1–1 Manchester United

A new back three, a Mbeumo goal and a better first half, then Leeds took over: six games without a win.

2 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
UCLManchester United · 13 OctAtlético de Madrid 2–0 Manchester United

Behind after 47 seconds, four big chances missed, down to ten at 74 minutes: United's night in Madrid.

2 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 10 OctManchester United 1–1 Tottenham Hotspur

Outplayed for an hour, ahead at 73 minutes, caught by ten men in stoppage time.

2 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 20 SepFulham 1–1 Manchester United

29 shots, a narrow loss on xG, and a deflection to rescue a point.

2 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
EFLManchester United · 16 SepManchester United 2–3 Brighton & Hove Albion

Two goals up after nine minutes, behind by the 69th: Manchester United lose at home from 2–0 up for the first time in 50 years.

5 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 13 SepManchester United 0–1 Manchester City

Manchester United had an extra man for 67 minutes and made 1.00 xG. Manchester City won with a goal the referees later admitted should have been checked.

1 goal animated · tactic breakdown · column →
UCLManchester United · 10 SepManchester United 4–0 Sabah FK

Manchester United return to the Champions League with a 4–0: patient for 27 minutes, then three goals before half-time.

4 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 6 SepEverton 2–2 Manchester United

Manchester United lead twice and are caught twice, by two long-range shots worth 0.07 xG between them.

4 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 30 AugManchester United 5–2 Ipswich Town

Behind after a Fatawu run, Manchester United answer with a Fernandes hat-trick, 33 shots and 4.77 xG.

7 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
PLManchester United · 22 AugHull City 2–0 Manchester United

Hull City's hidden back five and two Slater set pieces beat a flat Manchester United on opening day.

2 goals animated · tactic breakdown · column →
Before you start

How to read the diagrams

Every diagram plays on a loop like a short GIF: the dots are players moving, the white ball travels with the play, and lines trace where the ball and the runners went. Goal diagrams show the scoring team attacking up the page. Use Pause to freeze any moment. Diagrams are reconstructions from match reports and analysis, not tracking data, so positions are approximate.

Method and references

Sources

Facts (line-ups, minutes, stats, quotes) are cross-checked across at least two outlets where possible. xG sources are named in the notes above and in each match. Tactical claims are credited to the outlet that made them. YouTube analyses are linked, not transcribed. Everything under Column is our own analysis.